Verdicts and disagreement

Each final view references one proposal version and states a verdict:

Verdict	Meaning
APPROVED	The adviser supports this version of the proposal.
REJECTED	The adviser opposes it and keeps the objection on the record.
INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE	The adviser cannot judge it with the evidence available, and says what is missing.

Disagreement by design

Two approvals and one rejection are a valid outcome. A meeting is never extended to manufacture unanimity, and a polished summary must not erase an objection, missing evidence or an adviser’s dissent. In the recorded example, the Marketing Manager’s INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE stays beside the recommendation.

Your decision is separate

Adviser views and your decision are separate records. In the recorded example the decision stays pending: inspect both with decision. In the live preview, explicitly accept, reject, modify, defer or request investigation; no majority makes that choice for you. A material modification preserves old views as stale for the resulting proposal.

Confidence scores (0 to 100, the adviser’s declared assurance, never a calibrated probability or a voting weight) are included in the implemented live meeting contract; the recorded decision does not include them. Live workflow and qualification limits.